This article was written by John Nance Garner (1868 – 1967), FDR’s first Vice-President (1933 – 1941), who wrote a number of pieces for the readers of COLLIER’S MAGAZINE in 1948 outlining the various reasons for their contentious relationship.

“Cactus Jack” Garner bickered with F.D.R. on a number of issues; primarily supporting a balanced federal budget and opposing F.D.R.’s efforts to pack the Supreme Court. Within these attached pages, Garner tells how Roosevelt lost the support of his Democratic Congress.


This five page article is a segment of a longer one that laid out the cause for one of their most bitter arguments: the Flint Sit-Down Strike (1936 – 1937).


Read a 1933 article about FDR and the disaster that he tried to fix…





Was Henry Wallace a dirty Red?

Read John Nance Garner on F.D.R.<br>(Collier’s, 1948) for Free

Roosevelt on GM sit-in strikeFDR reaction to General Motors sit-in strike Flint Michigansenator joseph t robinson and FDRsenator alben barkley and FDRsenator pat harrison and FDRJohn Garner magazine article 1948FDR magazine article 1948Flint Sit-Down Strike magazine article 1948
Scroll to Top